
Educators: Earn a free Gold upgrade by joining the PBwiki Back To School Challenge.
You and others working in your medium will collaborate on designing a rubric for evaluating the final product, using the tools provided to you here.
With others in your group, find 3 examples online of productions that represent the full range of quality in the medium (make sure these are permanently and publicly accessible): these creations should show the full spectrum of what's possible, ranging from what you'd deem excellence (with all the appropriate bells and whistles that function to enhance the users' experience/understanding) to shoddy or poor work (that perhaps use bells and whistles simply for the sake of using them or, on the other hand, don't really maximize the medium's potential for enhancing the user's experience/understanding of the message).
Discuss with your group what makes these examples excellent, satisfactory, and poor.
Once you've agreed, copy links onto this wiki page, and briefly describe just beneath the link your rationale for your assessment of each.
Excellent
all of Pat's editing done in plum
Maddies editing done in pink
Dave's'll be in green
http://www.norwichnewyork.net/
Discuss: I like this website the best out of all the ones I have visited. It has a nostalic yet current feeling/effect. I think it achieves this with the photos moving from the past to the present. It is clean, with information in tabs.
http://www.deruyternygov.us/ This is a really nice website with cool and informative features. I will use this one as a model.
The school website
Its easy to navigate and not too hard on the eyes to boot.
http://www.cityofbinghamton.com/
I like the way this page is organized and links are easily accessible.
Final Choice:[Paste link here and remove this text]
Rationale (for selection as excellent -- in re: other candidates for this category and examples in other two):
Satisfactory
Dave's town website
http://www.bayportlife.com/
Discuss: Its not bad but it seems a little bland, I think a better website should look a bit more artfully done, no?
http://www.bubsmx.com/
This is my 17yr old little brothers website, hence why its satisfactory. The arrangement works well, but its not that interesting to look at and some of the links do not work.
This is Cortlands' very own official website. while very informative about current events, it isn't very appealing. Only one small tab about the history of Cortland.
Final Choice: [Paste link here and remove this text]
Rationale (for selection as excellent -- in re: other candidates for this category and examples in other two):
Poor
http://www.angelfire.com/super/badwebs/
Discuss: This website was designed to give all the bad examples that poor websites consist of. The "worlds worst website" informs those who are creating webpages what NOT to include on their page.
http://www.buydehydratedwater.com/
This is a fake website, obviously why its bad.
Just look at the site and you'll understand why its bad...
http://townofcazenovia.org/content This site was not visually appealing at all and it had just page of events. Very boring! The town also has a website done by the Chamber of Commerce, this is very appealing and informative but it had a members only section which I feel is uninviting to someone just wanting to know more about the town.
Final Choice:[Paste link here and remove this text]
Rationale (for selection as excellent -- in re: other candidates for this category and examples in other two):
Using the above example of excellence as your model, list the characteristics of a quality production in this genre/medium on the respective page of this wiki (click on the "Sidebar" link above);
Characteristics of Excellent Websites
[just continue to hit return after each entry above and you will continue to generate more numbers for each new line in your list].
When you are through, share this list with me to get approval before moving ahead to the next step.
Based on this work, create a rubric for all work in the medium at rubistar and save this rubric with a password and login that you note here:
Group login:
Group password:
Link to rubric:
Updated to a working one (4/21) - Rubric
I like how you included interest as a grading factor - some websites might be visually fantastic, but might not be interesting. Very thorough - I might be intimidated if I was making a site and this was my rubric! But thatts not a bad thing - it is very concise. -Garrett G
After class, you will share this rubric with classmates working with other media to make sure that the work/expectations are equitable across media. Classmembers not working in this medium must note their approval or suggest changes by making comments by the beginning of class on 4/7.
Taking into account my and other classmembers' comments, work with members of your medium group to revise the rubric. The revised and final rubric must be completed by class time on 4/14 (after which I will check and assess it).
List the name of your project and project team members's names and contact info here. Add lines to the table if necessary.
Name your project as follows: Your Project Name (medium). For example, NCLB in CNY (iMovie) or Cortland's Homeless (podcast).
| Project Name | Team Member | e-mail address | Phone Number |
| Cancer Awareness |
Maddie Foltyn |
Foltyn94@cortland.edu |
|
| Cancer Awareness |
Dave Mindich |
Mindich58@cortland.edu |
|
| town website | Pat Plummer | PPlummer@ovcs.org | |
| ELA and Technology | Bryan Welsh | progress_007@hotmail.com | |
project proposal.rtf Pat's proposal
Get out of the edit mode on this page by clicking on "Save" below. (As you work on this section, I recommend either printing this page out OR using two computers OR shuttling between two browser windows on the same computer: use one to make changes on, while reading these directions from the other).
Create a New Page
Create a Link to your New Page in the "SidebBar"
Creating a link from this page
Copy EVERYTHING on this page from "Production Schedule" to the bottom of this page (below) and paste it onto your Project Wiki Page.
Complete these tasks in this order (to be completed by 4/7):
Otherwise, this page is the space and creation of you and your group member's. Use it to collaborate asynchronously. But note that if you want to have a virtual meeting, you can insert a plugin from the toolbar above to engage in synchronous chat.
Working with others on your project team (most likely a subset of the "medium group," if there are several different projects being created in this medium"), you will create a Production Schedule for your project.
Steps:
TO DO LIST (See #2 above)
[just continue to hit return after each entry above and you will continue to generate more numbers for each new line in your list].
MIDTERM DRAFT
(See #3 above)
PRODUCTION SCHEDULE
M March 31 (PREPRODUCTION)
To do: Schedule group a) training and b) a "midterm"/follow-up meeting with Tera Doty-Blance (type dates of meetings below).
Person responsible: ____Pat is meeting with Tera 4/15/08_____________________
M April 7 (PREPRODUCTION/PRODUCTION)
Deadline: Project Proposal, Rubric, Production Schedule, and pre-filled Peer Evaluation forms
collaborative+work(2).rtf Pat's self-eval
M April 14 (PRODUCTION)
Deadline: Have met with trainer
M April 21 (PRODUCTION/POSTPRODUCTION)
Deadline: Draft of Project due
M April 28 (POSTPRODUCTION)
M May 5 (PUBLISH)
Deadline: Final draft due
Revised Project Proposal Attached Here
Pre-fill "Confidential Peer Evaluation" forms
Once you are finished with the Production Schedule, copy and paste from it in order to pre-fill the weekly "Confidential Peer Evaluation" forms and attach the completed, pre-filled form beneath the appropriate date below.
Pre-fill it by following these directions:
Be sure to divide this inputting among group members so that the work is equitably divided amongst group members. DUE: April 7
WEEKLY: Complete the "Confidential Peer Evaluation" forms
Each week, each group member will download one copy of that week's form, evaluate each group member's performance (including him or herself) BEFORE class begins, and submit the confidential form to me at the beginning of class. Forms not completed before class will not be accepted, and the indivdiual will receive "0" points for that week's assessment.
If individual tasks have changed since the form was first pre-filled, be sure to note these changes on the wiki no later than Monday at 8am for that day's evaluation.
Deadline: Project Proposal, Rubric, Production Schedule, and pre-filled Peer Evaluation forms
[Paste Pre-Filled Eval form here and delete this text]
collaborative+work(2).rtfM April 14 (PRODUCTION)
Deadline: Have met with trainer
[Paste Pre-Filled Eval form here and delete this text]
M April 21 (PRODUCTION/POSTPRODUCTION)
Deadline: Draft of Project due
[Paste Pre-Filled Eval form here and delete this text]
M April 28 (POSTPRODUCTION)
[Paste Pre-Filled Eval form here and delete this text]
M May 5 (PUBLISH)
Deadline: Final draft due
[Paste Pre-Filled Eval form here and delete this text]
Audience: Who is the audience (must be authenticaly related to ELA and technology, new media, new literacy, etc.)
Purpose: What is the purpose of your site?
"Tone": The look AND sound of the site should suit your audience and purpose
Dr. Sarver's del.icio.us acct:
search under "webdesign" and "web production"
On rss feeds:
https://www.socialtext.net/medialiteracy/index.cgi?rss
Page Information
|
Wiki Information |
Recent PBwiki Blog Posts |